组织韧性研究的脉络梳理与跨层次整合分析

doi:10.3785/j.issn.1008-942X.CN33-6000/C.2023.08.036

Abstract
Figure/Table
References
Related Citation (4)

Download: PDF (2127 KB) HTML (1 KB)
Export: BibTeX | EndNote (RIS)

Abstract Under the “new normal” that is full of changes and uncertainty, firms’ pursuit of stable development and sustainable operations is increasingly facing formidable challenges. To better understand how firms can withstand shocks and achieve growth in such a turbulent environment, this paper focuses on organizational resilience. Since resilience research involves different disciplines, although it has developed for decades in the field of organization and management, existing literature still fails in reaching a consensus on some basic theoretical issues, such as conceptual dimensions and emergence mechanisms. To advance further research in this domain, this paper, based on a systematic review of 146 articles on organizational resilience within the field of organization and management, provides a clear definition of organizational resilience and distinguishes it from similar concepts to better grasp the unique connotation of this concept. Our systematic review reveals that research on organizational resilience in different disciplines has led to diverse understandings of its essence. Building upon resilience research in ecology and psychology, this paper defines organizational resilience as “the inherent or learned ability of a firm to absorb, respond to, and recover from the internal and external shocks or disruptions, and even to transform them into new growth opportunities”. In addition, this paper analyzes the development trajectory and major theoretical perspectives of resilience research, showing the differences and associations among perspectives from ecology, psychology, sociology, and management within the field of organizational resilience research. Furthermore, this paper explores the influencing factors and mechanisms of organizational resilience at three levels: individual, group, and organization. It emphasizes that the construction of cognitive framework and organization atmosphere constitute important pathways through which individual-level and group-level factors can directly or indirectly impact the organization. Information and knowledge sharing also play an indispensable role in fostering organizational resilience. Incorporating the contingency factors of the emergence of organizational resilience, this paper establishes a cross-level integrated analysis model for organizational resilience research in an attempt to reveal the formation and emergence mechanism of organizational resilience. Finally, this paper suggests possible directions for future research from four aspects: time frame, measurement, cross-level interactions, and contingency factors. This paper makes three contributions to the literature. Firstly, integrating the theories in ecology and psychology, this paper clearly defines the connotation of organizational resilience and points out that organizational resilience includes three core elements: survival, recovery, and growth, laying a theoretical foundation for the subsequent development of accurate measurement tools for organizational resilience. Secondly, this paper analyzes the development and theoretical perspective of organizational resilience research and sketches a relatively complete theoretical map, which helps enhance the overall understanding of the theoretical progress of organizational resilience research. Thirdly, this paper investigates the influencing factors and mechanisms of organizational resilience at the individual, group, and organization levels, and establishes a cross-level linking mechanism, which provides an analytical framework for systematically understanding the micro-foundation and emerging mechanism of organizational resilience as well as a cognitive framework for bridging the gap between current theory and practice.

Key words： shock organizational resilience literature review cross-level integration

Received: 03 August 2023

	Service

	E-mail this article
	Add to my bookshelf
	Add to citation manager
	E-mail Alert
	RSS
	Articles by authors
	Zhao Yiting
	Dou Junsheng
	You Xialei
	Sun Dongliang

Cite this article:

Zhao Yiting,Dou Junsheng,You Xialei等. A Review and Cross-level Integrated Analysis of Organizational Resilience Research[J]. JOURNAL OF ZHEJIANG UNIVERSITY, 2024, 54(3): 64-85.

URL:

https://www.zjujournals.com/soc/EN/10.3785/j.issn.1008-942X.CN33-6000/C.2023.08.036 OR https://www.zjujournals.com/soc/EN/Y2024/V54/I3/64

1 Lengnick-Hall C. A.， Beck T. E. & Lengnick-Hall M. L.， “Developing a capacity for organizational resilience through strategic human resource management，” Human Resource Management Review， Vol. 21， No. 3 （2011）， pp. 243-255.
2 Coutu D.， “How resilience works，” Harvard Business Review， Vol. 80， No. 5 （2002）， pp. 46-50， 52， 55.
3 Alexander D. E.， “Resilience and disaster risk reduction： an etymological journey，” Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences， Vol. 13， No. 11 （2013）， pp. 2707-2716.
4 Williams T. A.， Gruber D. A. & Sutcliffe K. M. et al.， “Organizational response to adversity： fusing crisis management and resilience research streams，” Academy of Management Annals， Vol. 11， No. 2 （2017）， pp. 733-769.
5 Staw B.， Sandelands L. & Dutton J.， “Threat rigidity effects in organizational behavior： a multilevel analysis，” Administrative Science Quarterly， Vol. 26， No. 4 （1981）， pp. 390-405.
6 Meyer A. D.， “Adapting to environmental jolts，” Administrative Science Quarterly， Vol. 27， No. 4 （1982）， pp. 515-537.
7 Masten A. S.， Best K. M. & Garmezy N.， “Resilience and development： contributions from the study of children who overcome adversity，” Development and Psychopathology， Vol. 2， No. 4 （1990）， pp. 425-444.
8 Bonanno G. A.， “Loss， trauma & human resilience： have we underestimated the human capacity to thrive after extremely aversive events？” American Psychologist， Vol. 59， No. 1 （2004）， pp. 20-28.
9 Sutcliffe K. M. & Vogus T. J.， “Organizing for resilience，” in Cameron K. S.， Dutton J. E. & Quinn R. E. （eds.）， Positive Organizational Scholarship， San Francisco： Berrett-Koehler， 2003， pp. 94-110.
10 Williams T. A. & Shepherd D. A.， “Building resilience or providing sustenance： different paths of emergent ventures in the aftermath of the Haiti earthquake，” Academy of Management Journal， Vol. 59， No. 6 （2016）， pp. 2069-2102.
11 Linnenluecke M. K.， “Resilience in business and management research： a review of influential publications and a research agenda，” International Journal of Management Reviews， Vol. 19， No. 1 （2017）， pp. 4-30.
12 Wildavsky A.， Searching for Safety， New Brunswick： Transaction Books， 1988.
13 Lengnick-Hall C. A. & Beck T. E.， “Adaptive fit versus robust transformation： how organizations respond to environmental change，” Journal of Management， Vol. 31， No. 5 （2005）， pp. 738-757.
14 van der Vegt G. S.， Essens P. & Wahlstr?m M. et al.， “Managing risk and resilience，” Academy of Management Journal， Vol. 58， No. 4 （2015）， pp. 971-980.
15 Holling C. S.， “Resilience and stability of ecological systems，” Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics， Vol. 4， No. 1 （1973）， pp. 1-23.
16 Mithani M. A.， “Adaptation in the face of the new normal，” Academy of Management Perspectives， Vol. 34， No. 4 （2020）， pp. 508-530.
17 Hillmann J.， “Disciplines of organizational resilience： contributions， critiques， and future research avenues，” Review of Managerial Science， Vol. 15， No. 4 （2021）， pp. 879-936.
18 Adger W. N.， “Vulnerability，” Global Environmental Change， Vol. 16， No. 3 （2006）， pp. 268-281.
19 李平、竺家哲：《组织韧性：最新文献评述》，《外国经济与管理》2021年第3期，第25-41页。
20 Gallopín G. C.， “Linkages between vulnerability， resilience， and adaptive capacity，” Global Environmental Change， Vol. 16， No. 3 （2006）， pp. 293-303.
21 Dalziell E. P. & McManus S. T.， “Resilience， vulnerability， and adaptive capacity： implications for system performance，” https：//www.researchgate.net/publication/29489371_Resilience_Vulnerability_and_Adaptive_Capacity_Implications_for_System_Performance， 2024-01-22.
22 Fiksel J.， “Sustainability and resilience： toward a systems approach，” Sustainability， Vol. 2， No. 2 （2006）， pp. 14-21.
23 Ramezani J. & Camarinha-Matos L. M.， “Approaches for resilience and antifragility in collaborative business ecosystems，” Technological Forecasting and Social Change， Vol. 151 （2020）， https：//www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0040162519304494.
24 Taleb N. N.， Antifragile： How to Live in a World We Don’t Understand， London： Allen Lane， 2012.
25 Barton M. A. & Kahn W. A.， “Group resilience： the place and meaning of relational pauses，” Organization Studies， Vol. 40， No. 9 （2019）， pp. 1409-1429.
26 Gittell J. H.， Cameron K. & Lim S. et al.， “Relationships， layoffs， and organizational resilience： airline industry responses to September 11，” The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science， Vol. 42， No. 3 （2006）， pp. 300-329.
27 Warglien M.， “Intraorganizational evolution，” in Baum J. A. C. （ed.）， The Blackwell Companion to Organizations， Malden： Blackwell， 2002， pp. 98-118.
28 Weick K. E.， Sutcliffe K. M. & Obstfeld D.， “Organizing and the process of sensemaking，” Organization Science， Vol. 16， No. 4 （2005）， pp. 409-421.
29 Linnenluecke M. & Griffiths A.， “Beyond adaptation： resilience for business in light of climate change and weather extremes，” Business and Society， Vol. 49， No. 3 （2010）， pp. 477-511.
30 Linnenluecke M. K.， Griffiths A. & Winn M.， “Extreme weather events and the critical importance of anticipatory adaptation and organizational resilience in responding to impacts，” Business Strategy and the Environment， Vol. 21， No. 1 （2012）， pp. 17-32.
31 Weick K. E.， Sutcliffe K. M. & Obstfeld D.， “Organizing for high reliability： processes of collective mindfulness，” in Staw B. & Sutton R. （eds.）， Research in Organizational Behavior， vol. 21， Greenwich： JAI Press， 1999， pp. 81-123.
32 Buyl T.， Boone C. & Wade J. B.， “CEO narcissism， risk-taking， and resilience： an empirical analysis in U.S. commercial banks，” Journal of Management， Vol. 45， No. 4 （2019）， pp. 1372-1400.
33 Sajko M.， Boone C. & Buyl T.， “CEO greed， corporate social responsibility， and organizational resilience to systemic shocks，” Journal of Management， Vol. 47， No. 4 （2021）， pp. 957-992.
34 Mallak L.， “Putting organizational resilience to work，” Industrial Management， Vol. 40， No. 6 （1998）， pp. 8-13.
35 Santoro G.， Messeni-Petruzzelli A. & del Giudice M.， “Searching for resilience： the impact of employee-level and entrepreneur-level resilience on firm performance in small family firms，” Small Business Economics， Vol. 57， No. 1 （2021）， pp. 455-471.
36 Casprini E.， Pucci T. & Zanni L.， “From growth goals to proactive organizational resilience： first evidence in women-led and non-women-led Italian wineries，” Review of Managerial Science， Vol.17， No. 10 （2023）， pp. 1017-1036.
37 Branicki L.， Steyer V. & Sullivan-Taylor B.， “Why resilience managers aren’t resilient， and what human resource management can do about it，” The International Journal of Human Resource Management， Vol. 30， No. 8 （2019）， pp. 1261-1286.
38 Anwar A.， Coviello N. & Rouziou M.， “Weathering a crisis： a multi-level analysis of resilience in young ventures，” Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice， Vol. 47， No. 3 （2021）， pp. 864-892.
39 Dimitriadis S.， “Social capital and entrepreneur resilience： entrepreneur performance during violent protests in Togo，” Strategic Management Journal， Vol. 42， No. 11 （2021）， pp. 1993-2019.
40 Protogerou A.， Kontolaimou A. & Caloghirou Y.， “Creative industries and resilience in times of crisis： the role of firm and entrepreneurial team characteristics，” International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behavior & Research， Vol. 28， No. 4 （2022）， pp. 1075-1105.
41 Kahn W. A.， Barton M. A. & Fisher C. M. et al.， “The geography of strain： organizational resilience as a function of intergroup relations，” Academy of Management Review， Vol. 43， No. 3 （2018）， pp. 509-529.
42 Azouz A.， Antheaume N. & Charles-Pauvers B.， “Looking at the sky： an ethnographic study of how religiosity influences business family resilience，” Family Business Review， Vol. 35， No. 2 （2022）， pp. 184-208.
43 Tognazzo A.， Gubitta P. & Favaron S. D.， “Does slack always affect resilience？ a study of quasi-medium-sized Italian firms，” Entrepreneurship & Regional Development， Vol. 28， No. 9/10 （2016）， pp. 768-790.
44 Weick K. E.， “The collapse of sensemaking in organizations： the Mann Gulch disaster， ” Administrative Science Quarterly， Vol. 38， No. 4 （1993）， pp. 628-652.
45 George G.， “Slack resources and the performance of privately held firms，” Academy of Management Journal， Vol. 48， No. 4 （2005）， pp. 661-676.
46 Sirmon D. G.， Hitt M. A. & Ireland R. D. et al.， “Resource orchestration to create competitive advantage： breadth， depth， and life cycle effects，” Journal of Management， Vol. 37， No. 5 （2011）， pp. 1390-1412.
47 Ambulkar S.， Blackhurst J. & Grawe S.， “Firm’s resilience to supply chain disruptions： scale development and empirical examination，” Journal of Operations Management， Vol. 33-34， No. 1 （2015）， pp. 111-122.
48 Kim S.， “Frame restructuration： the making of an alternative business incubator amid Detroit’s crisis，” Administrative Science Quarterly， Vol. 66， No. 3 （2021）， pp. 753-805.
49 Kahn W. A.， Barton M. A. & Fellows S.， “Organizational crises and the disturbance of relational systems，” Academy of Management Review， Vol. 38， No. 3 （2013）， pp. 377-396.
50 Liu Y. & Yin J.， “Stakeholder relationships and organizational resilience，” Management and Organization Review， Vol. 16， No. 5 （2020）， pp. 986-990.
51 Lee J. Y.， Yahiaoui D. & Lee K. P. et al.， “Global talent management and multinational subsidiaries’ resilience in the Covid-19 crisis： moderating roles of regional headquarters’ support and headquarters-subsidiary friction，” Human Resource Management， Vol. 61， No. 3 （2022）， pp. 355-372.
52 Richtnér A. & L?fsten H.， “Managing in turbulence： how the capacity for resilience influences creativity，” R&D Management， Vol. 44， No. 2 （2014）， pp. 137-151.
53 Bhamra R.， Dani S. & Burnard K.， “Resilience： the concept， a literature review and future directions，” International Journal of Production Research， Vol. 49， No. 18 （2011）， pp. 5375-5393.
54 DesJardine M.， Bansal P. & Yang Y.， “Bouncing back： building resilience through social and environmental practices in the context of the 2008 global financial crisis，” Journal of Management， Vol. 45， No. 4 （2019）， pp. 1434-1460.
55 Leuridan G. & Demil B.， “Exploring the dynamics of slack in extreme contexts： a practice-based view，” Human Relations， Vol. 75， No. 6 （2022）， pp. 1167-1193.
56 van den Berg J.， Alblas A. & le Blanc P. et al.， “How structural empowerment boosts organizational resilience： a case study in the Dutch home care industry，” Organization Studies， Vol. 43， No. 9 （2021）， pp. 1-27.
57 Hamel G. & V?likangas L.， “The quest for resilience，” Harvard Business Review， Vol. 81， No. 9 （2003）， pp. 52-63， 131.
58 Ates A. & Bititci U.， “Change process： a key enabler for building resilient SMEs，” International Journal of Production Research， Vol. 49， No. 18 （2011）， pp. 5601-5618.
59 Parker H. & Ameen K.， “The role of resilience capabilities in shaping how firms respond to disruptions，” Journal of Business Research， Vol. 88 （2018）， pp. 535-541.
60 Do H.， Budhwar P. & Shipton H. et al.， “Building organizational resilience， innovation through resource-based management initiatives， organizational learning and environmental dynamism，” Journal of Business Research， Vol. 141 （2022）， pp. 808-821.
61 Reinmoeller P. & van Baardwijk N.， “The link between diversity and resilience，” MIT Sloan Management Review， Vol. 46， No. 4 （2005）， pp. 61-65.
62 Barney J. & Felin T.， “What are microfoundations？” Academy of Management Perspectives， Vol. 27， No. 2 （2013）， pp. 138-155.
63 Felin T.， Foss N. & Ployhart R.， “The microfoundations movement in strategy and organization theory，” Academy of Management Annals， Vol. 9， No. 1 （2015）， pp. 575-632.
64 Conz E.， Lamb P. W. & de Massis A.， “Practicing resilience in family firms： an investigation through phenomenography，” Journal of Family Business Strategy， Vol. 11， No. 2 （2020）， pp. 1-16.
65 Hadjielias E.， Christofi M. & Tarba S.， “Contextualizing small business resilience during the COVID-19 pandemic： evidence from small business owner-managers，” Small Business Economics， Vol. 59， No. 3 （2022）， pp. 1351-1380.
66 Dewald J. & Bowen F.， “Storm clouds and silver linings： responding to disruptive innovations through cognitive resilience，” Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice， Vol. 34， No. 1 （2010）， pp. 197-218.
67 Turner N.， Kutsch E. & Maylor H. et al.， “Hits and （near） misses. exploring managers’ actions and their effects on localised resilience，” Long Range Planning， Vol. 53， No. 3 （2020）， pp. 1-17.
68 Gucciardi D. F.， Crane M. & Ntoumanis N. et al.， “The emergence of team resilience： a multilevel conceptual model of facilitating factors，” Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology， Vol. 91， No. 4 （2018）， pp. 729-768.
69 Barton M. A.， Sutcliffe K. M. & Vogus T. J. et al.， “Performing under uncertainty： contextualized engagement in wildland firefighting，” Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management， Vol. 23， No. 2 （2015）， pp. 74-83.
70 Al-Atwi A. A.， Amankwah-Amoah J. & Khan Z.， “Micro-foundations of organizational design and sustainability： the mediating role of learning ambidexterity，” International Business Review， Vol. 30， No. 1 （2021）， pp. 1-11.
71 Ortiz-de-Mandojana N. & Bansal P.， “The long-term benefits of organizational resilience through sustainable business practices， ” Strategic Management Journal， Vol. 37， No. 8 （2016）， pp. 1615-1631.
72 Chrisman J. J.， Chua J. H. & Steier L. P.， “Resilience of family firms： an introduction，” Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice， Vol. 35， No. 6 （2011）， pp. 1107-1119.
73 Gao C.， Zuzul T. & Jones G. et al.， “Overcoming institutional voids： a reputation-based view of long-run survival，” Strategic Management Journal， Vol. 38， No. 11 （2017）， pp. 2147-2167.
74 Carmeli A. & Markman G. D.， “Capture， governance， and resilience： strategy implications from the history of Rome，” Strategic Management Journal， Vol. 32， No. 3 （2011）， pp. 322-341.
75 Gherardi S. & Strati A.， “The temporal dimension in organizational studies， ” Organization Studies， Vol. 9， No. 2 （1988）， pp. 149-164.
76 Conz E. & Magnani G.， “A dynamic perspective on the resilience of firms： a systematic literature review and a framework for future research，” European Management Journal， Vol. 38， No. 3 （2020）， pp. 400-412.
77 Ding W.， Levine R. & Lin C. et al.， “Corporate immunity to the COVID-19 pandemic，” Journal of Financial Economics， Vol. 141， No. 2 （2021）， pp. 802-830.
78 Kantur D. & Iseri-Say A.， “Measuring organizational resilience： a scale development，” Journal of Business Economics and Finance， Vol. 4， No. 3 （2015）， pp. 456-472.
79 张秀娥、滕欣宇：《组织韧性内涵、维度及测量》，《科技进步与对策》2021年第10期，第9-17页。
80 Christianson M. K. & Barton M. A.， “Sensemaking in the time of COVID-19，” Journal of Management Studies， Vol. 58， No. 2 （2021）， pp. 572-576.
81 Campopiano G.， de Massis A. & Kotlar J.， “Environmental jolts， family-centered non-economic goals， and innovation： a framework of family firm resilience，” in Memili E. & Dibrell C. （eds.）， The Palgrave Handbook of Heterogeneity among Family Firms， London： Palgrave Macmillan， 2019， pp. 773-789.
82 Korbi F. B.， Ben-Slimane K. & Triki D.， “How do international joint ventures build resilience to navigate institutional crisis？ the case of a Tunisian-French IJV during the Arab-Spring，” Journal of Business Research， Vol. 129 （2021）， pp. 157-168.
83 Li L.， Wang Z. & Ye F. et al.， “Digital technology deployment and firm resilience： evidence from the COVID-19 pandemic，” Industrial Marketing Management， Vol. 105， No. 10 （2022）， pp. 190-199.
84 Brockner J.， “The escalation of commitment to a failing course of action： toward theoretical progress，” The Academy of Management Review， Vol. 17， No. 1 （1992）， pp. 39-61.
85 Branzei O. & Fathallah R.， “The end of resilience？ managing vulnerability through temporal resourcing and resisting，” Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice， Vol. 47， No. 3 （2021）， pp. 831-863.